Best Practices for a Positive Candidate Experience

Good help is hard to find, but it doesn’t have to be!

Candidate experience is one of the most important factors in an organization’s hiring success, and investing in the process can strengthen your employer brand and make it easier to attract top talent. 

Benefits of a Positive Candidate Experience 

Believe it or not, there are countless benefits to a positive candidate experience, even regarding candidates who are not selected for the job! 

Though it’s disappointing not to be offered a job, if candidates feel respected and valued throughout the interview process, they’ll still leave with a positive impression of your organization. 

A positive candidate experience can help distinguish your organization in a competitive hiring market through positive word-of-mouth and candidate referrals. It can also lead to more engaged employees, higher retention rates, and increased employee satisfaction. 

Treating candidates fairly and being transparent in the hiring process also helps organizations avoid legal risks, preventing unnecessary legal fees or a tarnished reputation. 

This can also save your organization money and improve the hiring process, as candidates who feel they were treated well are more likely to accept job offers. 

Finally, a positive candidate experience influences how potential customers perceive your brand and can create a talent pipeline for future opportunities. 

Preparing the Foundation for a Positive Candidate Experience

Now that we’ve covered the benefits of a positive candidate experience, let’s look at the tactical steps you can take to ensure all candidates feel respected and appreciated, no matter the outcome of their interview. 

The easiest way to improve your candidate experience is to put yourself in a candidate’s shoes. 

If you spent hours filling out a job application or working on a skills assessment and didn’t even receive feedback or an automated email response, you’d probably feel discouraged and would form a negative perception of the employer. 

To prevent these negative feelings, take steps to ensure candidates know your organization appreciates the time and effort required to apply for a position. 

Best Practices for a Positive Candidate Experience 

The candidate experience encompasses all interactions between the candidate and your organization. 

That means that even if you put effort into ensuring interviews are professional, fair, and efficient, another aspect of the candidate experience could be bringing your reputation down. 

Therefore, it’s important to monitor all aspects of the candidate experience and strive for constant improvement. 

1. Effective Communication and Timely Feedback

One of the essential best practices is maintaining clear and transparent communication with candidates. Providing timely updates on the hiring process and informing candidates about the steps involved helps manage their expectations and keeps them engaged. 

Depending on the specifics of your job application, filling it out can take a significant amount of time. Reassure candidates that you’ve received their application by sending an automated receipt to their email address once they submit their documents. 

If possible, provide an estimated timeline for the hiring process and ultimate decision, allowing candidates to plan appropriately. Though not always appropriate, candidates not selected for the role will often appreciate constructive feedback to help them improve their application. 

Throughout the process, organizations should also offer clear instructions on interview logistics and provide feedback on candidates’ progress, as transparency and open communication build trust and create a positive impression of the organization.

2. Create an Easy Application

Beyond thanking applicants for applying, strive to make the application process itself as smooth as possible. Candidates may be less upset about not proceeding to the next round of hiring if they experienced an efficient application process that didn’t feel like a waste of time.

If possible, avoid asking candidates to repeat information across different parts of the application, and consider using a tool such as Indeed’s Easy Apply that can scan resumes and automatically populate some sections of the application. 

Consider implementing short video-form interview questions instead of a screening call or interview. Rather than asking candidates to take time out of their days and reserve a live interview slot, they can record their answers to questions on their own time. 

Of course, real-time interviews are critical later in the process, but you can optimize the early stages by moving candidates through as efficiently as possible. 

3. Streamlining the Interview Process

During the interview stage, organizations should conduct candidate-centric interviews that focus on the candidate’s experiences, skills, and cultural fit. Providing a positive and comfortable atmosphere during interviews can make candidates feel at ease and enable them to perform at their best. 

Respect for candidates’ time is also crucial during interviews. Offer the option for a virtual interview, as this can make it easier for candidates to find time in their schedules. 

Sticking to the scheduled interview time and avoiding unnecessary delays demonstrates professionalism and consideration for candidates’ schedules. It’s also crucial to ensure that all interviewers are adequately prepared to provide a professional and efficient experience. 

4. Personalization and Engagement

Personalization is another key element in creating a positive candidate experience. Addressing candidates by name and tailoring communications to their interests and experiences demonstrates that the organization values them as individuals. 

Personalization can be achieved by referring to specific aspects of a candidate’s background in communications and interviews. With minimal effort, personalizing interviews can foster a sense of connection and engagement, making candidates feel that their interviewer took the time to learn their details and professional history. 

Sharing details about company culture or scheduling will help candidates feel connected to the process. If possible, involve potential team members in the interview process to give candidates an idea of what their team dynamic might be like if they are offered a role. 

Finally, be sure to provide an opportunity for the candidate to ask any lingering questions, ensuring that they have all the information they need. 

5. Respect and Professionalism

Employer branding is a powerful tool in shaping the candidate experience. Organizations should leverage various channels like the company website, social media, and employee testimonials to showcase their culture, values, and employee experiences. 

A well-defined employer brand attracts top talent and gives candidates insights into what it’s like to work for the organization, helping them assess cultural fit. To improve your employer brand, strive to treat all candidates with respect and dignity. 

Be on the lookout for discriminatory practices and unconscious biases in your hiring process, and always handle sensitive information with confidentiality. 

6. Managing Candidate Rejections

Prompt follow-up is equally important for a positive candidate experience. After each stage of the process, organizations should provide timely updates on candidates’ status. 

Whether they progress to the next round or not, keeping candidates informed of their status shows respect for their time and effort. 

When you do need to share bad news, be sure to do so promptly and graciously. If possible, provide constructive feedback to rejected candidates and encourage them to stay in touch in case any relevant opportunities pop up. 

Maintaining good relationships with all candidates will help your organization build and maintain a talent community, easing the hiring process and boosting your employer brand. 

7. Onboarding and Beyond

Even though onboarding is not technically part of the hiring process, it is still the first interaction candidates will have with your organization after accepting a job offer. 

Provide a smooth and well-structured onboarding process and encourage your team to welcome new hires with warmth and enthusiasm. 

Measuring and Evaluating the Candidate Experience

Finally, your organization should always be working to improve the candidate experience. 

Organizations should regularly gather feedback from candidates about their recruitment journey. Feedback can be collected through surveys or informal conversations, and used to identify areas for improvement in the recruitment process. 

When organizations put this data to good work and make changes accordingly, candidates and employees alike will appreciate their commitment to constantly improving the candidate experience.

Conclusion

A positive candidate experience will ripple out to all aspects of your organization, including hiring, productivity, employee morale, and your company’s reputation. 

Commit to constantly improving your candidate experience by implementing the best practices laid out in this article, ensuring that all candidates who experience your hiring process leave with a positive impression of your organization.